Audio compressed again?

Randy Brown wrote on 8/4/2003, 7:00 PM
Hi,
I had an Mpeg2 burned to DVD; after viewing, my client wanted a CG script at the end changed. I brought in the mpeg2 into V4 and made the change and re-rendered (as an mpeg2). Now DVDA wants to compress the audio again. This is a piano concert and I certainly don't want to lose any more quality. Any thoughts?
Thanks,
Randy

Comments

Randy Brown wrote on 8/4/2003, 7:29 PM
Also, I sometimes make a 1-5 minute DVD for clients. Now I understand that AC-3 is a good thing, but isn't there some way to overide this compression?
Thanks again,
Randy
SonyEPM wrote on 8/6/2003, 9:29 AM
If you want the highest quality audio, render a separate PCM (.wav) audio file in Vegas, marry that with the MPEG in DVDA, and choose PCM as the compression option in DVDA.
Randy Brown wrote on 8/6/2003, 2:52 PM
Thanks SonicEPM,
So in V4, render the Mpeg2 as usual (default) but also render a .wav; then double-click both in DVDA to add to menu and then select optimize (from the "Make DVD" dialogue)then PCM in the drop-down under media audio settings?
Thanks again,
Randy
SonyEPM wrote on 8/7/2003, 11:21 AM
Render an MPEG-2 using one of the DVD Architect render templaes, and render again as 48k PCM wav, same name, same folder as the mpeg. Load those in DVDA, choose PCM in the optimize dialog and the files should be able to be prepared for burning without recompression. Check the DVD Arch help file for no-recompress format settings.
Randy Brown wrote on 8/8/2003, 9:29 AM
Sorry but I'm back.
Okay, to keep this breif: Yesterday, I rendered a .wav of the project and tried to select it in the media properties/audio dialogue (to the right of the timeline) but I get the error "Selected file is not of the required type". I spent quite a bit of time on the menu selection and hope I don't have to do it again but I wonder if I need to render the mpeg2 again as video only to work with the .wav I created.
Thanks,
Randy
Randy Brown wrote on 8/8/2003, 1:06 PM
All was well until I started to actually prepare and burn. The dialogue I spoke of accepted the video only and the .wav so I went to optimize and selected PCM on everything and it still says it's going to recompress! What am I missing here?
Thanks,
Randy
Randy Brown wrote on 8/8/2003, 3:26 PM
So I started from scratch, added my markers for chapters in V4, added the 48k, 24 bit .wav and video only mpeg2. Everything looked great until I started to render when I get "Warning an error occured while writing a file. The reason for the error could not be determined. FWIW, both files play fine in Windows Media Player.
mdsh wrote on 8/14/2003, 7:25 AM
Make a 16 bit wav not a 24 bit wav.
ZaphodB wrote on 8/15/2003, 11:54 PM
Basically, as "SonicEPM" said you need to render as follows:
1. render a DVD mpeg2 "VIDEO ONLY" format to produce a video file that does not have an included audio track encoded in the video file. It produces a video only file. As stated previously, Vegas' "DVD Architect" templates produce this kind of output.
2. render a second time, but this time creating an audio only output in the wave format, 16 or 24 bit, 48k mono or stereo (whichever is appropriate). This produces a second separate audio only track. The name of it should be the same name as the file in step '1', but with a 'wav' extension.
3. In DVDA, add the video track where you want it and DVDA will automagically "marry" the separate audio file with it. If not, then simply click on the video thumbnail and choose the audio track you created in step 2.
Randy Brown wrote on 8/16/2003, 9:48 AM
Thanks eveyone! Support e-mailed a few suggestions to me. This particular project has been a "back-burner" kinda thing, but I should be able to try their tips this weekend.
Thanks again,
Randy