Build or buy complete? (New computer

matt d wrote on 4/2/2010, 2:11 PM
Like the title says what would most of you do when it comes time to get a new computer?

I'm editing short videos in AVCHD and have about $1000 to burn on the whole project. Right now I'm using a HP laptop and it's a nightmare.

The one thing I would love to see is some smooth playback during editing.

Build or buy complete.....?

Comments

david_f_knight wrote on 4/2/2010, 5:54 PM
Not to discourage you from building your own computer, but most people just don't have the temperament or desire to do what's necessary to build their own computer. It definitely requires much more time and effort on your part to do all the research required to select the components for building a good system at a low cost, than to buy a complete computer system.

Unless you're willing to make that commitment, your question is moot.

There are definite advantages to building your own computer, if you are willing to invest the time to do it properly. I have built all my computers for years and can't imagine ever buying a complete system again. But I don't recommend others do the same unless they have a real interest in doing so.

All anyone can do is tell you what's right for them, not what's right for you. The very fact you've asked this question suggests that you have never built a computer before. The actual process of building a computer is not that hard, but the process of choosing which components to buy is where most of the work lies, especially if you don't know what the issues are. If you are still considering it, I suggest shopping around a bit to get an idea of what's available at what prices and what the issues are. If you find yourself completely lost and bewildered, then buy a complete system. But if you enjoy reading about the different components and view the process as an interesting challenge, then building your own computer might be for you.

Here's a thread about this very topic and with some advice.

And, there's always plan B: if your principle goal is just to have smooth playback during editing, then perhaps you should keep your current computer and look into transcoding your AVCHD video sources to some other format that requires less horsepower to work with. There are others here that have taken that approach and could give advice about that.
musicvid10 wrote on 4/2/2010, 8:09 PM



My thought is that by feeling a need to ask the question, you have answered it for yourself.
Buy new.
matt d wrote on 4/3/2010, 2:42 AM
I had a good friend offer to build it for me. If it wasn't for him I would never have thought about a build.

I went to Best Buy and heard they do a 18month no interest payment plan. I'm now looking at buying....

At first I was looking at the HP "gaming" pc's with 8 or 9 GB's of RAM. Then they starting trying to talk me into an iMac that only had 4 GB's for about the same price as the pc. The Mac guy was saying that the 4GBs on the Mac is equal to 8 on a pc. Any thoughts on this?

So many choices.

Is it safe to say that as soon as you spend over $1000 on a new computer you should have a good working system for editing??
Chienworks wrote on 4/3/2010, 4:52 AM
"The Mac guy was saying that the 4GBs on the Mac is equal to 8 on a pc. Any thoughts on this?"

That sounds a lot like the old Apple ads claiming that Macs were better because they handled all 128 bits simultaneously whereas PCs could only handle 32 bits at a time. This was quickly shown to be utterly false, especially since both systems were only using hybrid 16/32 bit processors at the time.

I suppose what the salescritter might be alluding to is that there *might*, just might be some native Apple software that happens to handle memory more efficiently that it can accomplish in 4GB what some similar Windows software needs 8GB for. However, that would be a specific case and i'm sure that counter examples could be found too. Considering your situation is that you wish to run Vegas under Windows, the argument is completely moot.

So, short answer: 4GB is only half of 8GB, no matter what system you're running.
Ivan Lietaert wrote on 4/3/2010, 5:44 AM
Why not do the following:
1) buy cineform's neoscene (to transcode avchd) to make it editable. $99 at Videoguys.com
2) Buy a 2TB external drive: $180
3) Buy 2 extra 32GB SD cards $180
4) Save the rest, or buy a very nice lens

If you really need to upgrade, buy a mac mini. iMovie will play avchd files fluently, they say.