Comments

JSWTS wrote on 4/15/2003, 2:40 PM
No.

Jim
Bear wrote on 4/16/2003, 9:10 AM
What program offers css protection? Just curious I did not think you could do that.
Thanks
jetdv wrote on 4/16/2003, 11:11 AM
I've heard that the new Adobe Encore program will allow setting the macrovision flag. However, it would still have to be replicated in order to be effective. Bear, I'd like the answer to that question as well.
JSWTS wrote on 4/16/2003, 3:56 PM
Spruce's Maestro and Sonic's Scenarist are two off the top of my head. I believe Mac's DVD StudioPro will allow you to do this as well.

Jim
jetdv wrote on 4/16/2003, 3:59 PM
This is on burned DVD-r? NOT Replicated?
jdupre wrote on 4/17/2003, 1:22 PM
How about that Macromedia copy protection scheme that makes the output fluctuate in brightness when copied via analog connection? Is that something that can be used with DVDA or other inexpensive DVD authoring tool and burned to DVD General media?

- joe
swattum wrote on 4/17/2003, 6:05 PM
I believe it's called Macrovision.

Given the variety of software available (both free on the internet or boxed if you're foolish enough to waste your money) to defeat both CSS and Macrovision (most DeCSS programs will also remove Macrovision protection for you) it seems kind of a useless feature (either of them) for a product to have.

If people want to copy the material on a DVD, you're not going to be able to stop them.
yirm wrote on 4/17/2003, 8:03 PM
> I believe it's called Macrovision.

I believe you are correct. Macromedia deals with a different kind of CSS (Cascading Style Sheets).

-Jeremy
frawley wrote on 4/18/2003, 10:37 AM
first of all, the CSS we are talking about is Content Scrambling System that is on DVDs, NOT Cascading Style Sheets which apply a theme troughtout a website. Two COMPLETLY seperate things.

and yes CSS is a deterrant, sure some people if they really want to can break it, but these people are technically savy for the most part. almost all people can hook a DVD up to a VCR and record. CSS does cut back on some piracy!
JSWTS wrote on 4/18/2003, 5:46 PM
CSS and Macrovision are both typically used on Hollywood dvd's to prevent copying. CSS is used to prevent direct digital copying of the disc to optical (DVD recordable) media. Macrovision is used to prevent DVD to VHS copying. Both are relatively easily defeated by software, but I do agree with frawley for the most part it takes a fair amount of knowledge to do this. Because of that, casual copying is reasonably deterred with these protection schemes. With that all said, recent programs (DVDXCopy for one) have been released that allow for direct disc copying. One other deterrent that Hollywood uses is creating content with file sizes that exceed a recordable dvd (dual layer discs are becoming the norm).

If you are creating discs (like Hollywood) that will have mass appeal, then the cost of copy protection schemes is worth it. It won't stop everyone, but a majority. If one is creating discs for a smaller audience (events, weddings, and the like), then the cost isn't (IMO) worth it. You make your money on creating the content the first time with a high profit per disc ratio. I generally throw in an extra copy for the the customer anyway because dvd recordable media is much more susceptible to scratches and smudges causing playback failure. Hollywood makes less profit per disc, but hopes to make up for it in volume. Not much mass appeal outside the bride and groom's own personal interest in their wedding dvd(perhaps the immediate family and wedding party).

Jim