In developement or under-developement?

1stbass wrote on 12/2/2003, 11:28 AM
I 'upgraded' to V.5 because Sonic Foundry had abandoned V.4 - no updates to enable the use of the latest burners, for example - and I looked forward to all the improvements I assumed I'd find... mmmm? It's hard to imagine that a new issue of a product will turn-out to be LESS functional than its predecessor (the revised volume-envelope control, anyone?) but this has certainly been the case with CDA5 (and not forgetting CD text, of course! ...and an issue with rippping ISRC numbers consistently).

Sony was once (and possibly still is) divided into a 'professional' and 'domestic' operations. It was the 'domestic' side of Sony that opened a window on the world of digital recording for the small operator with the introduction of the F1 PCM encoder and the DAT machine, but the 'professional' arm of Sony which perceived these as corporate own-goals and a threat to the market of their infinitely more expensive products. Perhaps they view CDA in a similar light?
Conversly, as it's quite likely the 44.1k, CD format will be abandoned in the very-near-future (let's hear it for the 5.1-remastred verision of Robert Johnson), it may be that Sony feel there is little point is flogging a dead horse.

The great thing about CDA4 was that you could ALMOST master a CD with it but with V5 this possibility has become more elusive. The likelyhood is, that for one reason or another, this is exactly the way Sony like it.

Anything else around?

Comments

Geoff_Wood wrote on 12/5/2003, 8:55 PM
Sorry, how do you think that CDA5 is less able to master a CD than CDA4 ?

The only thing missing in 5 is CD-TEXT (not Red-Book BTW ) . CDA4 totally lacked plugins, so how would you 'master' there ? What has 'ripping ISRC codes got to do with mastering ?? Whatever makes you think CD's demise is imenent ???

geoff
Rednroll wrote on 12/6/2003, 12:02 AM
The CD's demise is emminent, but not for awhile, especially with the battle of SACD vs. DVD-A going on. Another beta vs. Vhs battle where everyone is sitting back waiting for the winner to emmerge before the focal point development occurs.

A DVD burner is finally on my Christmas list, but not for delivering DVD-A product, but more for archival and video reasons, and the ability to put my entire 250 cassette collection onto a single DVD in .MP3 format and free up some space in my storage closet. I can put one DVD in my DVD player which supports .MP3 and have better quality, less space, and a virtual jukebox controled by a remote control. I couldn't ask for much more. Another reason I think CD's won't go away too soon is because there aren't any radio stations that broadcast in 5.1 yet, not even XM radio which claims to be CD quality, but only has a broadcasting bandwidth of 15Khz. A little short of CD at a 22Khz bandwidth. I think I'll put my 5.1 mixes on an encoded stereo mix CD, that way I have control of what the encoder is doing, instead of letting a radio stations DVD player do that for me.