OT - Anybodys guess

MUTTLEY wrote on 2/19/2004, 12:01 AM
Okay, so I'm bound and determined to make a video screensaver to distribute on my site. Out of the dozen or so that I downloaded and tested the shareware, this one stood out as the best:

http://www.21hua.com/

Several reasons, but I won't expound unless someone cares. Regardless, as it supports vid I made the loop in Vegas and rendered as an avi. Looks great in Vegas, looks good on external, but I noticed the middle logo looks horrible. So I opened it up with just Windows Media Player, and by golly it looks awful there to. Here's the avi file if you would like to see what I'm taking about:

www.undergroundplanet.com/misc/screensaver.zip

So I've tried exporting in every possible format, avi, mpeg, quicktime, wmv, same result with all. I've tried doing the logo as a png with transparency, a psd with transparency, tried putting it on a colored background and chromakeying it out ... all the same. No matter what I seem to do it only looks good in Vegas ( and I would bet it would look fine on a DVD. I use almost the same animation as the background for my menus ) So, after spending about 12 hours more than I planed to chasing this little problem and re-rendering it a million times, thought I'd ask for a little input. Even though this is ultimately for just a screensaver, the problem has bigger implications that just that.

So, anyone ?


- Ray

www.undergroundplanet.com

Comments

cyanide149 wrote on 2/19/2004, 4:19 AM
Looks great on my monitor- don't see the problem....
MUTTLEY wrote on 2/19/2004, 2:44 PM
Looks great in Vegas or in Windows Media Player or both ? The image that is looking jacked is the Underground Planet logo in the middle, in Windows Media it looks jagged and compressed, all the letter and the circles that are part of the logo.

- Ray

www.undergroundplanet.com

RichMacDonald wrote on 2/20/2004, 8:37 AM
I can confirm it looks crappy on Windows Media. Severe compression artifacts to my eye. Unfortunately, no Vegas on my work computer, which is where I am right now.

Just for grins, why not try a different color and see if it makes a difference. The artifacts appear to come from the bright shadows (an oxymoron, but the background underneath the text), which is sufficiently bright and close to red that this could be a problem -- isn't bright red supposed to be one of the problematic colors to avoid? Also try and soften the edges of the text, since the hard transition between solid-black and solid-other is where compression might not be able to keep up with the detail.