OT: Best "Affordable" Video Projectors

Coursedesign wrote on 12/22/2004, 12:27 PM
I had to get a new training projector, so I did a bit of research.

If you need to use it for Powerpoint etc., you should get a 4:3 projector (they still do good 16:9), and you should get at least 1024x768 NATIVE resolution.

Anything less than that, you can expect the very ugly Screen Door Effect (from the pixels showing). You can still get SDE at 1024x768, but manufacturers have found ways to virtually eliminate the problem at that resolution.

Note that some projectors say "Resolution 1600x1200!!!!" and then in tiny print "native resolution 1024x768".

For presentations in brightly lit rooms, you need lots of lumens. This used to be very expensive, now it's available for a lot less.

If you are going to use it only for watching HD content, get a true 16:9 projector with native 1280x720 resolution.

A stunning example of this is Hitachi's PJTX1000, a 3-panel LCD projector that has exceptional ED optics and sells for $2800 street in the U.S. (and about 1450 euro elsewhere, grrrr). The projected image on this thing simply looks three-dimensional, totally blows away everything under $8K or so, and blows away a lot of projectors over that, too.

Why native 16:9? Let's start with SVGA, the most common resolution, it's 800x600 in 4:3. In 16:9, we get 800x432... That's 432 lines, not so hot.

With 1024x768, you get at least 1024x554, ie. 554 lines (progressive at least).

...and the 1280x720 gives you just that, no loss at all, a full 720 lines.
Btw, it still looks great when watching 1080i content on DirectTV etc.

Obsolescence comes quickly. Projectors that sold for $8,000 - $12,000 last year are now going unsold at a very SMALL fraction of those prices. For good reason, the technology has moved so quickly.

Prices can change weekly right now, and it's good to check if the model you are buying is still manufactured, this will affect the price curve.

Best 1024x768 projectors at around $1500-ish right now:

Optoma EP 739 (aka Ez Pro 739)
2300 lumens
2000:1 contrast ratio
DDR (Double Data Rate) DLP (DDR eliminates or reduces the rainbow effect that some people see)
5.3 lbs., comes with a high quality padded carrying case
DVI input (makes it possible to get an all-digital video connection from a HDTV tuner and/or DVD player
HDCP (may be important to access secure content as it becomes available)
RGB & YUV component inputs
5,000 hour lamp life in Eco-mode (which is plenty bright), else 3,000 hours.
27dB noise (about the SPL of a leaf thinking about rustling)
Zoom lens
and lots more good stuff...
Truly amazing picture for both PPT and video
2-year warranty (this is no joke, repairs are pricey for projectors)
Price $1499 at J&R if bought through Amazon.com (else $1599). Free screen via mail-in request that takes "up to 8 weeks."
Price $1519.99 at www.bestbuy.com (not available in stores), with a free decent quality six-foot screen shipped simultaneously.
Manufacturing started July 2004, still made as far as I can tell.


BenQ PB8220
2200 lumens
2000:1 contrast
2,000 hours lamp life (no Eco mode)
features similar to the Optoma, but no DVI input and hence no HDCP
limited inputs
6.8 lbs.
FCC Class A (commercial use only)
34 dB noise
$1495 on eBay BuyItNow!
various prices elsewhere, some including a spare lamp (worth $399.95)
Manufacturing stopped Dec. 2003.

Both of these are from good major manufacturers, and have received very very good reviews. They stand out for offering lots of light and high contrast ratio in a portable package, with a very very good video image also.

I couldn't find anything else that came even close at these prices.

Comments

beatnik wrote on 12/22/2004, 1:52 PM
I bought the Epson Powerlite S1+ for $900.00 (CDN) reg $1200 on sale.

Is this a good model?
Coursedesign wrote on 12/22/2004, 5:33 PM
That Epson is a really good projector at that price, and it beats most of those costing twice that.
Coursedesign wrote on 12/25/2004, 3:06 PM
I got the Optoma EP 739, and have been using it for a few days now.

It really is exceptionally good for this price, even for HDTV and DVD projection.

DVDs look very filmic.

Over-The-Air HDTV looks very crisp, especially after I got a DVI-D cable so there is no D/A and A/D conversion in the chain at all.

Lots of light. Good contrast. Highly recommended for as little as $1519 including a free screen.


farss wrote on 12/25/2004, 5:36 PM
JVC are using some fancy new LCD technology that has overlapping pixels so you cannot see them even up very close.
Now I don't know about the US but downunder JVC are not known for their stellar service and as this kind of gear is expensive that could be a big factor. Still the images do look stunning.
Bob.
Coursedesign wrote on 12/25/2004, 10:02 PM
I'm no fan of JVC stuff either, never found it to be as durable as the competition.

Several projector manufacturers have reduced the screen door effect substantially, and I certainly don't see it on my Optoma even at 100 inches.

If you really want to see marvelous movie quality, get a Hitachi PJTX1000.

It uses 3 native 1280x720 LCD panels and an ED lens that is absolutely stunning to make a totally smooth image that looks just 3-dimensional. This puppy sells in Europe for 1450 euros, which is totally unfair to your poor American cousins who have to pay at least $2800 (best price I saw at an authorized retailer) for the same thing.

:O( snif!



farss wrote on 12/26/2004, 2:19 AM
1450 euro is about USD 2800. Actually I've noticed a few in the US complaining about the cost of things over there recently, all I can say is welcome to the real world, when your dollar goes down the price of imports goes up! Our dollars has come pretty close to double what it was worth a few years ago, so cameras and the like are getting a bit cheaper down here. Well actually that's not quite true, it means the agents are making twice the markup.
Bob.
Coursedesign wrote on 12/26/2004, 4:39 PM
USD1.35/euro x 1,450 euros = USD1,957.50.

It is true that we used to be spoiled here, and in some cases still are.

I have a DP friend in Sweden who recently balked at paying SEK12,000 for Combustion 3 locally when it was half that in the U.S. for the exact same box.