OT: computer service rating

apit34356 wrote on 10/16/2006, 8:27 PM
From IT Hardware news;

Who makes the most reliable computers? Lenovo, closely followed by Apple, if you believe online service and support company Rescuecom's latest reliability audit, derived from more than 20,000 calls made by the firm's customers during the second quarter this year.

Rescuecom assigned a reliability rating to computer vendors. Lenovo, in its guise as provider of IBM desktops and notebooks, scored 243. Apple attained 201. Third-placed HP/Compaq scored a mere 12. Dell's rating was 4, Gateway -12 and all the rest together scored -16.

What's in a number? According to Rescuecom, the scores factor each vendor's US market share - the data's from Gartner, it said, and covered the last four years - against the number of support calls the company received for each manufacturer's products. The result is a measure of how likely it is to receive a cry of help regarding a given vendor's offering, all other factors - like the fact there are a lot more Dells out there than Macs - being equal.

The higher the score, the less likely Rescuecom reckons it will be to receive a support call concerning that vendor's products - a benchmark, it believes, for the reliability of those products.

Apple, for instance, has a quoted US market share of 4.02 per cent but accounted for only two per cent of Rescuecom support calls. Dell, on the other hand, has a US market share of 17.9 per cent, but accounted for 29.4 per cent of help requests made to Rescuecom. Of the top five vendors, only Gateway kit generated more support calls than the company's market share would suggest.

Of course, Rescuecom focuses on providing IT support to businesses, so it's customer base doesn't necessarily match the demographics of the broader computer technology user base. Apple has a lower Rescuecom support-call likelihood than its market share would suggest, but is that a sign of greater reliability, or a relative paucity of Apple users among Rescuecom's customers? And how will the big battery recalls of Q3 2006 change the scores?

Rescuecom was also quick to claim that even Gateway's reliability is "solid". It said the same of HP and Dell, claiming those vendors' product reliability was merely "potentially less so" than Apple or Lenovo. Which is a bit like saying: Lenovo machines are more reliable than Dell's. Only they might not be...
..................................................

I'm firm believer in IBM laptop durability.

Comments

DrLumen wrote on 10/16/2006, 11:50 PM
That's an interesting observation they have made and you posted.

I would think their statistics are conjecture at best. For example, how does IBM upgraded warranties or service contracts affect their stats? Likewise, with Dell or any other manufacturer service contracts. If someone has an IBM, 4 hour onsite contract for service of a server, that company is not going to call a 3rd party vendor (rescuecom) for service. They will call IBM directly.

How about system lifecycle? Case in point, there must be millions of HP Laserjet 5SI printers still in service. Would they count it as negative for service on that printer or would it be a plus since it is 11 years old and still being used? Granted, their stats are focused on PC's but you can see how that eample might apply to PC's or servers.

How about physical damage, say someone driving a truck over a laptop? (it happens more than you might think) How are those issues figured into the stats? The more the market share of the manufacturer, the more likely this type of scenario would happen.

Working for a fortune 500 computer sales/service company, which is likely a direct competitor of rescuecom, I know there are A LOT of variables in their study which they could only guess or tilt one way or the other.

As to the last statement referring to "it may be wrong", they are not wanting to piss off any particular manufacturer. These stats also leads me to believe they are not authorized service providers of any manufacturers or they would not have gone anywhere near releasing this 'report'.

Just my 2c.

intel i-4790k / Asus Z97 Pro / 32GB Crucial RAM / Nvidia GTX 560Ti / 500GB Samsung SSD / 256 GB Samsung SSD / 2-WDC 4TB Black HDD's / 2-WDC 1TB HDD's / 2-HP 23" Monitors / Various MIDI gear, controllers and audio interfaces

FrigidNDEditing wrote on 10/17/2006, 12:28 AM
I tried DELL, Never again, I'm Trying HP (I think I've got it figured out with them, but we'll see), and If Lenovo had offered what I wanted, I would have gone their route, they just didn't have what I wanted).

Sager notebooks are pretty high quality I hear too. In fact I'm pretty sure that a lot of the alienware and other suped up laptops are just re-wrapped sagers.

Dave
bevross wrote on 10/17/2006, 5:59 AM
There was an interesting review of highend laptops in PCMag recently --

http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,2024864,00.asp

"In one of the high-end gaming laptops [Alienware, bought by Dell], the temperature in the system's base hit 114 degrees. The highest temperature we encountered was a whopping 120 degrees [Winbook]." Battery life on most of these was in the 2.5 hour range!

I had a look at a Dell three years ago & was appalled by the noise & heat (returned within the 30 day no-questions-asked period; these days I think there's a restocking fee). If I was in the market for a laptop now I'd still look at the Dell's (the Inspiron E1505 was well reviewed in the article above), and I have a Thinkpad (last of the IBM's, before Lenova took over). Lenova demands a greater premium for high end features, it seems.
FrigidNDEditing wrote on 10/17/2006, 9:41 AM
Bev, I'm returning my E1505 as we speak, because they still have not fixed the (adapter not recognized) issue with the weak solder spots on the motherboard. I've had it with them. As for Lenovo/IBM I think Lenovo was already making much of the thinkpads and then decided to buy out IBM (but why oh why would anyone get rid of SUCH A RECOGNIZABLE NAME?!?!?, Beyond me). Anyway, I don't care how it was reviewed, in the world of laptops DELL = C R A P - outright, IMHO.

Dave
je@on wrote on 10/17/2006, 9:52 AM
Lenovo made IBM laptops for years. IBM got out of the laptop biz and, of course, will not license the brand to another company. There was a short period of logo overlap then Lenovo became the brand name.