OT: Lost video archive partition? (Poof! Gone!)

kentwolf wrote on 1/2/2005, 8:47 PM
Has anyone seen this:

I create an NTFS partition, and all is fine.

Then, after some drive-inensive operations such as file copying or defrag, the partition simply disappears? Windows disk manager reports it is unallocated space. Partition Magic as well as Acronis Disk Director all report it as un-allocated space. During file copying, I received a message that thus and such directory was corrupt and the directory could not be read. Previoulsy, the directory was just fine. All AVI files played perfectly. No issues at all.

This has happened *twice* now to me within the last few days on a new 300 GB (Maxtor) drive I was archiving raw video footage on. I have never had this phonomena before. I lost about 8 hoours of analog to digital footage. It is all recoverable, however, 8 hours of run time has now been wasted.

Some specifics:

1.) This is drive #10 in my tower of drives.

2.) I ran the latest (long duration test) Maxtor diagnostics and all said the drive was fine.

3.) Initially, an Acronis Disk Director-created partition disappeared after a defrag operation. (Primary partition)

4.) The second partition to disappear was a standard-stock (native) Win XP Pro-created NTFS partition during a large file copy operation. (Primary partition)

5.) This is a fixed drive on an IDE cable. IDE #2, slave.

Has anyone else ever seen this? I certainly have not.

**I was wondering if maybe my power supply (300 watt) was not big enough, could this be a factor? I do not have any spurious reboots, crashes, etc. My systrem runs terrific.

Any insight would be most helpful. I would like to work this out before redoing my lost archive footage.

Thanks much!

Comments

kentwolf wrote on 1/3/2005, 5:19 AM
Bump...
TheHappyFriar wrote on 1/3/2005, 7:45 AM
You sure your MB/IDE controller card supports drives above 128gb?
kentwolf wrote on 1/3/2005, 7:59 AM
Thanks. No problem on the IDE controller/drive size.

I just got off the phone with Maxtor and the drive is a bad one. Out of the 15 Maxtor drives I have, this is the first bad one I have ever had.

They are going to replace it with no problems.

It is unusual that the Maxtor PowertMax utility/diagnostics showed *no* problems, however, both Norton Utilities and another separate SMART monitoring utility both showed SMART problems with the drive and that failure was imminent. These SMART warnings showed up after my initial post. I even tried changing the drive letter on the presumed bad drive, and the same physical drive showed problems, regardless of drive letter. The SMART warning messages plus the fact that I completely lost two (2) NTFS partitions certainly seem to indicate the drive is bad.

Perhaps the PowerMax diagnostics tolerances are a little high so it fails *just* after the warranty expires... :)

Fortunately, chkdsk was able to restore one of the lost partitions, so I was able to recover all of my data. but the drive still indicates imminent failure based on multiple SMART monitoring programs. Presumably the SMART warnings are to let you know in time so you can get your data backed up. I have never, ever had any SMART warnings on anything. I used to wonder if it even worked.

Well, I guess it does.

Thanks!
musicvid10 wrote on 1/3/2005, 9:10 AM
Even though you have a bad drive, 300w is underpowered for the number of hard drives you have IMO. I got disk corruption with four HD's and 2 ATAPI's on a 300w PS and switching to a 400w cured it completely.
BillyBoy wrote on 1/3/2005, 9:14 AM
Something else you can check to see the "health" of your drives if you're using Windows XP.

Control Panel, Performance and Maintenance, Administrative tools, then click on Computer Management, finally on Disk Management.

There you should see all your hard drives listed and Windows will show them as "healthy" or not. If not, time to try one of Window's build-in repair tools and it may, underscore MAY repair the drive. I know it works with NTSF, not sure if it does under FAT 32 systems.

Trying to recall from my memory...

About a year ago one of my drives was acting up, it didn't show as healthy, I clicked on a few options and Windows went into some extreme undocumented recovery routine, like checkdisk on sterorids and sector by sector it looked at the drive, found lots of problems and fixed them all, Drive has been "healthy" even since. Go figure. Took well over a hour with all kinds of weird messages flying by on the screen but Windows did something. <wink>
shogo wrote on 1/3/2005, 6:45 PM
If there is any important data on the partition you can try R-Studio I used this to recover a Vegas project that was on a drive that lost it's partition. I also used it to recover a bunch of pics off of a CF Card that for some reason lost all the pictures according to the camera and several card reader's. There is a demo that you can try to verify if it can see and recover the data but it only allows tiny files to be actually recovered. Here's the link to it if interested.
It's also pretty cheap like $49
http://www.r-studio.com/?RTTSL001
kentwolf wrote on 1/3/2005, 9:39 PM
Thanks guys for the input.

>>...300w is underpowered for the number of hard drives you have IMO...

I just installed a 680 watt power supply. Just fired it up! That oughta do it. :) (Hopefully, I'll also get an AMD 64 bit something or another for my birthday = Dual-purpose power supply.) :)

>>...you can check to see the "health" of your drives...

All drives showed as healthy. Even the bad one.

>>...you can try R-Studio...

I will definitely give it a look.

Thanks again!