Problems with Sonic DVDiT 5.2 and MS

ZumaZ wrote on 1/27/2005, 12:25 PM
I wanted a little more in my DVD authoring program so I bought DVDiT (at half price) for $150. I wanted the ability to encode to AC-3 audio and I wanted to get around the silly .vob file sizes that DVD Architect Studio seems to make. I have to re-author my VIDEO_TS folders with DVD-Shrink to avoid the Nero "reallocation of files failed" error with TS folders made by DVD AS.

At the moment, however, DVDiT seems to be useless to me. Problem is, when I render to mpg OR avi (tried several versions of each in "advanced render") DVDiT says the files are non DVD compliant. Furthermore (and this is probably a different problem altogether) Sonic DVDiT tells me I am missing codecs and displays nothing but a green screen. The files play fine in Windows Media Player with the exception of any uncompressed.avi files. They play with a NASTY stutter. For example, with an avi file I created from a .vob with VirtualDub Video Inspector gives me a thumbs down on the video codec and says I need a DIB codec? Isn't that already included with XP? What codec should I install. I have the Gordian Knot pack.

I can play "DV-AVI" files I brought in from my DIgiCam in any program. These were imported using MS. Apparently these are using the Sony codecs. These same "DV-AVI" files, however, can NOT be imported into Sonic's program either! Once again, it complains about the lack of Codecs.

Is it just me or does it seem that Sony MS/VF only wants to place nice with itself? I don't want the hassle of re-saving the output of MS just to use it somewhere else. Any ideas?!?!?!

Comments

IanG wrote on 1/27/2005, 3:07 PM
> DVDiT says the files are non DVD compliant

Does it give any indication of what's non-compliant? I've used MS' MPEG2 files in DVD-Lab and it hasn't raised any compliance issues. The DVDs play fine, even on Sony players, which tend to be "sensitive" about such things.

Ian G.
ZumaZ wrote on 1/28/2005, 2:02 PM
Ok, using Huffyuv to render to AVI seems to make DVDiT happy and that also tackles the stuttering AVI issues I was having. Almost there!

IanG, I too have used MS' MPEG2 files in other programs and it just seems DVDiT is so damn picky. Since the files I have are already MPEG2 (recorded from my MSI capture card) It seems pointless to go to AVI just to satisfy DVDiT. I would like to know how I can render to another MPEG2 encoder in MS AND which one will work for sure. When you choose the MPEG option in Advanced render the "Custom" button becomes grayed out. Even if I bought another MPEG2 encoder how would I tell MS to use it?

Or I could just "re-save" the output from MS with another program to make it compliant but the waste of time is what I was trying to avoid in the first place. Any ideas on what free program I could use that might do this quickly?