Remote Desktop?

MichaelS wrote on 11/11/2004, 7:06 PM
Has anyone tried to use Windows XP Remote desktop? I'm considering setting up my studio system so I can monitor/activate rendering, etc. from home. I have a T1 at work and cable at home.

They're several "pay" systems available, such as "gotomypc.com", but is that necessary if both systems are running XP Pro?

Also, is there a downside to instituting this system for occassional use?

Comments

Spot|DSE wrote on 11/11/2004, 7:17 PM
I've never used gotomypc.com before, but HAVE done online training using Microsoft's Remote Assistance tools and Vegas. It's slow, but it works. Course', I wasn't streaming/loading the avi's over the web, either.
Liam_Vegas wrote on 11/11/2004, 7:18 PM
It should work just fine for you. I use remote desktop to access servers remotely and I can see no reason why it should not be possible to use for your purpose. Just don't expect to be able to do any <editing:> remotely.

You'll need XP Pro on your studio system to do this.

There are also a few other remote control programs - one I use is called Remote Admin 2.
johnmeyer wrote on 11/11/2004, 7:36 PM
I just completed a consulting assignment with a startup that is getting into the GoToMyPC space. Also, I used to run a company that, long ago, made a product that looked exactly like Netmeeting, which is sort of a forerunner to Remote Desktop.

The big issue is the firewall. Any "takeover" of the remote requires that you somehow breach the corporate firewall. This can be done by port forwarding the router, but this means your IT manager will have to cooperate. The other way, that doesn't ivolve the IT manager is to use an external service that can convert all traffic into standard IP requests, so that the traffic looks exactly like the traffic from a browser.

There are also issues of performance. Some of the long-established products that have been around for almost twenty years, like PC Anywhere, have amazing tricks embedded in them that will cache all sorts of things so that performance improves the longer you use the same application remotely.

Obviously you should start with Remote Desktop. It's free, and if it works, don't look any farther. If you run up against the (fire)wall, then try GoToMyPC. Be forewarned that their free trial is VERY difficult to cancel. They use a lot of the same tactics made famous years ago by companies selling record album subscriptions that you could never get to stop.
BJ_M wrote on 11/11/2004, 7:44 PM
i use a program which runs through a SSL connection based on REALVNC (winVNC), but is more secure .. called TRIdaVNC Pro



Orcatek wrote on 11/11/2004, 7:51 PM
Remote desktop works great. You have to turn it on in XP on the desktop you wish to control. Remote PC and even be Windows 2000 as long as you install the client.

If you run into problems with the port with a firewall you can change the port in the registry - check google. Then you just access the remote machine via xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx:#### where ## is the port you chose.

I prefer to move it from the default anyway as it keeps people from finding it and trying anything.

vicmilt wrote on 11/11/2004, 8:03 PM
I've been using gotomypc.com for a couple of years now, and love it.
Sometimes I'll be monitoring my second machine from across the room, sometimes from out of state. It's all the same.
You can't really "edit" but you CAN select areas for rendering, setup titles and basically anything that doesn't take a lot of muscle power.
I use one machine to take all of my email and then monitor the emails via gotomypc.com, from basically anywhere. That way all email is on one machine, in one place.
I also can do layouts, graphics and DVD layouts via the web.
I also screen stuff for clients from my machine, with them as guests.
I'm not a sales shill for gotomypc - just a satisfied customer.
Paradox wrote on 11/12/2004, 7:34 AM
I use remote desktop and have no problems with most programs. However, I have found Vegas to be problematic. Not sure why.
jogga wrote on 11/13/2004, 12:06 PM
I have tried using Remote Desktop to monitor how long my render has come, but when I log onto the computer I get an error and the render stops.
farss wrote on 11/13/2004, 3:36 PM
I used both RDP and VNC, uStuffs RDP sure works well BUT most of the systems I work with are limited to 800x600 and 16 colors. Once you start to push the video res up performance goes down so probably trying to run a large desktop for video editing would be very, very slow if it held together at all.
However for monitoring and starting / stoping renders remotely should be just fine.
Bob.