Single frame picture compilation

johnmeyer wrote on 4/17/2005, 4:52 PM
I want to add an "extra" to a DVD that contains a large number of still pictures. I want this to take the absolute minimum space on the DVD. Ideally, each picture would be one frame of video and would display indefinitely until the user presses the chapter advance button. What is the best way to take the absolute minumum amount of space per picture?

[Edit]

No one replied to this post yet, so I thought I would add something.

I experimented and found that a picture compilation is the worst possible way to put still (non-animated) pictures into a DVD, if you are concerned about space. Thirty pictures (with no soundtrack) resulted in a VIDEO_TS folder that contained 79 Mbytes!!

I then started a new project, and put the exact same thirty pictures into a Music Compilation, and it only 9% of the space, or 6.8 Mbytes. It prepared a lot faster too (about 10x faster).

I am sure there is some advantage to a picture compilation, or Sony wouldn't have invented it and called it "picture compilation," but I'm not sure why I would use it. Certainly for my immediate needs, the music compilation is the way to go.

Ah, I just found another thread that explains it all. Don't know why I didn't find this when I searched earlier:

Slideshow from 10 JPGs - Smaller if created as "Music Compilation"

Comments

bStro wrote on 4/17/2005, 7:05 PM
Or just use whichever kind of compilation you want and lower the bitrate as much as possible.

Rob
johnmeyer wrote on 4/17/2005, 8:31 PM
Thanks. I know think I get it. The picture compilation creates the pictures as a traditional MPEG stream, wherease the music compilation simply puts the picture in a single "I" frame and then puts this on the screen for the duration of whatever music has been added. If you don't add music, the picture stays on the screen for five seconds. I haven't found a way to change that default, but I'm sure there is some hidden setting in the registry that can be changed. I don't think you can change it without attaching music to each picture.