Still confused about parent track nesting

smhontz wrote on 4/28/2004, 6:34 AM
Ok, I've seen how you can apply an FX to all the children in the nest by using the pre/post toggle switch in the FX. But I'm still confused about how the nest works when applying the 2D shadow and glow to the parent. Here's the example, working from a new project:

1. To tracks 1 - 4, add a generated media color, one to a track. Use yellow, green, blue and orange.
2. In each tracks track motion dialog, size them to 240 x 160 and put them in a different corner of the screen.
3. Now add a new track one, select all the tracks below it, and make them all a child of the new track 1.
4. In the parent motion dialog, turn on 2d glow. NOTHING HAPPENS. Now add, an additional track 6 below all the child tracks, and drop a white generated color. Now you can see the glow on the child tracks. HOWEVER, THE GLOW IS EDGED DIFFERENTLY AROUND ALL THE CHILD OBJECTS.
5. Turn on the 2d shadow in the parent motion dialog. You get a nice 2d shadow around all the children, and it is offset exactly the same around each child - down and to the right.

So, what I'm confused about is:
1. Why do you have to have media below all the children for the glow to show up?
2. Why does the glow go around each child object with different offsets?

Comments

JohnnyRoy wrote on 4/28/2004, 7:16 AM
> 1. Why do you have to have media below all the children for the glow to show up?

I am guessing this is because you added the glow to the parent composite and not the track itself. The composite needs something to project onto (i.e., be composited with)

> 2. Why does the glow go around each child object with different offsets?

Because the glow is emanating from the parent track which is centered on the screen. So the glow is growing out from the center of the parent track and NOT the center of each individual track. You don’t see this with the shadow because the shadow is an offset in one direction which doesn’t change. If you move your PIP’s around the screen you’ll see how the glow is emitted from the center. This is different than turning glow on for each track which would emanate from the center of that track's motion.

~jr
chaboud wrote on 4/28/2004, 11:17 AM
Try nudging the parent track's parent-position a tiny bit.

There appears to be a bug in which the Parent track's Parent-glow is not applied if it has no motion or media.

Thanks for the find.
JohnnyRoy wrote on 4/28/2004, 12:39 PM
Wow the nudge worked! I guess its a bug. ;-)

~jr
chaboud wrote on 4/28/2004, 1:51 PM
And it will be corrected in the next point release.

Again, smhontz, thanks for the nice find.