vv3 woes

mayberryman wrote on 12/26/2001, 2:51 PM
I've spent hours trying to zero in on the source of my difficulties. I'm hoping that this info will be useful to you "guru's". I appreciate any help.

I moved up to Vegas Video 3.0 from Ulead Video Studio 4.01. In the UL product, I can render a test file as .avi using the "DV Video Encoder" for compression, to produce a type-1 .avi file (17,685KB) or I can render with "no compression" (153,002KB).

Both files will play using windows media player.

TMPGenc ver. 2.0 will accept both files for transcoding to vcd compliant mpeg-1 files.

Using VV3.0 and the same test file, I can render to .avi using the NTSC DV template (18,704KB) or the default (uncompressed) template (203,648KB)

Both of the VV3 files choke in wmp, the uncompressed file much worse (by choke..I mean audio/video is there but video freezes...jerky..etc.).

TMPGenc will NOT accept the VV3.0 DV encoded file, but will accept the uncompressed file.

My efforts with the UL product allowed me to produce a vcd of apprx 19 min. with a 4 gig file made using their DV encoded file.

If I must go uncompressed using vv3, I estimate I'll get roughly 90 seconds with a 4 gig file...utterly useless.

Last but not least, if I choose to use VV3's mpeg-2 encoder and select the SVCD video type, VV3 ALWAYS gives an error message stating that "an error occured while creating the media file. The reason for the error could not be determined." VV3 will not encode a SVCD compliant mpeg-2 file for me.

Now, I know how powerful vv3 is for nle...I bought it!
I know it's more powerful than Ulead Video Studio could ever be.

BUT.......I'm getting real depressed, hopeless, filled with buyer's remorse, (fill in with your own sad description)....since I can't use my vv3 easily edited files. I'm sure it MUST be something I'M doing wrong. Please set me straight!

Thanks!

Comments

wvg wrote on 12/26/2001, 3:09 PM
You covered a lot of ground. :-)

I just upgraded from Video Factory to Vegas Video. You should be able to get a tad less than 7 minutes of uncompressed AVI in a single file if you're using the FAT32 file system, assuming you're using Windows 98SE.

If you export to TMPGEnc as uncompressed AVI (I did) in Video Factory, you can always join smaller files using MPEG tools in that application. I just limited the AVI file size in VF (can do same in VV) to no more than 6 minutes assuming you're still using FAT32. NTFS has no such limitation.


If you upgrade to Win 2000 or XP and elect the NTFS file sytem there is no file size limit. I've made 40GB size files with Video Factory, I'm sure Vegas Video will do the same, haven't done one with VV3 yet.

Sadly the Microsoft Media Player chokes with regularity regardless what codec the video was made with. This is a fault in Media Player. The newest version that comes with XP seems more stable. There are many other video players other than WMP that are far better. Some free, others shareware.

I haven't had time yet to do any serious testing of VV3. I would be interested in the results others got rendering to both VCD and SVCD then burning with Nero.