Is there anyway to get DVDA detect the field ordering of a source file and encode to match it? The progressive scan DVDs that I have made are wonderful, and I'd like to be able to do the same thing even for files that DVDA thinks it has to reencode.
What application do you use to make your progressive scan DVDs? Do you have a progressive scan T.V. to view it on. I don't know much about progressive scan and would like to learn.
I don't know if I am producing a "real" progressive scan DVD as per the actual spec, BUT when I produce a DVD with a progressive scan MPG2 from the Main-Concept CODEC, as long as DVD-Architect doesn't reencode it, then I can see the difference on my Sony progressive scan DVD player. Even on an interlaced display (i.e. a normal TV set) the file acts different.
For a DVD with interlaced mpg source, the "pause" algorithm for the DVD player seems to freeze the frame on a version of the frame with just the odd field, but doubled (i.e. the even field is replaced by the odd field) to fill the right amount of space.
But I can render the same source material into a progressive scan MPG2 file, and DVDA burns a DVD that, when paused, will show both fields frozen perfectly.
The effect is most observable when rendering several seconds of a still computer-generated image, or a composite passage where there is a prominent piece of CGI (such as the Warner Bros. shield logo at the beginning of a lot of movies). When the constant pic is there, I can pause and unpause back and forth, and on the interlaced version I will see the paused version get "chunky", but with the PS version, pause is indestinguishable from a playing continuous picture.
BTW, I talked with SonicFoundry tech support about this, and I was not believed about the phenomenon that I observed. I have to figure out a way to take pictures of my TV in such a way that people will believe me :-)