Comments

seeker wrote on 3/8/2003, 5:12 PM
Beatnik,

You probably meant Copy Protection instead of Write Protection. Well, when you rent a commercial DVD it usually has MacroVision protection that prevents you from just hooking up the output of your DVD player to the input of your VCR and copying the DVD directly to a VHS tape. However, people have figured out how to "RIP" a DVD in various ways, or "hack" the DVD player itself, and copy a DVD despite the copy protection of MacroVision. I am sure if the big Hollywood studios can't keep people from copying their DVDs that you probably can't either.

-- Seeker --
nolonemo wrote on 3/10/2003, 11:14 AM
Some higher-end authoring programs such as DVD Maestro will allow you to enable Macrovision protection. CSS encryption can only be done, I believe, by commercial disk pressing houses, athough Maestro will set up your master for it.

Neither of these will prevent someone who is determined to copy your disk from doing so. The software is readily available for those who want to bother.
JSWTS wrote on 3/10/2003, 2:12 PM
beatnik,

There are two commonly used methods of protecting Hollywood dvd's as nolonemo references: Macrovision and CSS encryption. Macrovision can be used with DVD-R(recordables), but requires a high end authoring application to accomplish. It (macrovision) is what prevents a user from hooking their dvd player directly to their VHS and making a copy (the video feed is scrambled).

CSS encryption is used to prevent direct copying of discs. This can not be performed on a recordable disc, and requires a higher end authoring application to prepare the project (usually sent to a replication house via a DLT tape) before it's replicated. The replication facility has the means of incorporating the encryption onto glass mastered discs. As nolonemo mentions, means to circumvent the encryption have been devised, and there currently is a program that allows for direct disc copying.

I do a lot of 'one offs', and the extra cost of such encryption just isn't worth it. It's unlikely that these discs are going to have mass appeal, and these protection schemes generally are pretty effective for stopping the casual copier. You make your money on creating the content in the first place. I generally toss in an extra copy for free as a backup, because the DVD-R media is more prone to damage than a Hollywood, glass mastered disc (the user will often treat the two as though they are the same).

Jim
w4crobster wrote on 3/13/2003, 4:51 PM
BEST PROGRAM: DVDXCOPY
www.dvdxcopy.com
beatnik wrote on 3/13/2003, 8:47 PM

By the way Seeker was right, I did mean copy protection!
w4crobster wrote on 3/18/2003, 5:46 PM
Burn Write Protection Projects

Back up ur Dvd's you bought!

www.dvdxcopy.com