DVCPRO 50 or Quicktime uncompressed?

dhill wrote on 1/26/2006, 12:51 AM
Hello! I have a client, well I guess I'm the client since I am an actor in her film, and she was handing out dvd's that she made of the rough edits at a film festival this week. They didn't look very good at all compression wise...lots of articfacts.

Any way, I wanted to help her out and take her file and make a master dvd for her to make copies from to present to people. I'm sure I could get a better result with Vegas/DVD arch. She's using FCP and she shoots in DVCPRO 50 format. I've done some searching and it looks like Vegas doesn't support that, so, I was thinking maybe a Quicktime uncompressed file would be a good way for me to import into Vegas and render to MPEG2.

So, if that is a good solution, my last question would be what format does a hard drive need to be in so both a Mac and a PC can read/write? I had to do FAT32 about 5 years ago when hiring someone to master a dvd for me using DVD Studio Pro. It was a bit of a nightmare. I had to split my video into 2 files so they wouldn't be larger than 2GB or was it 4GB. I forget. Any way, that messed up my chapter points and I had to make the chapter points start over again half way through the video (2nd vid file).

So, has the FAT32 file size limit thing changed or am I still stuck in the same situation? I just need to get her very large file from her Mac into Vegas. Thanks as usual for your input. DH

PS When doing searches for other posts on particular subjects, I am constantly shaking my head at some of the people who post a question on this forum and then start yelling at others (through text) who are trying to help them. It baffles me. I really can't understand how anyone could react that way towards someone else who has taken the time out of their day to write back...whether it helps the person posting or not. There...I'm done venting. :o)

Comments

farss wrote on 1/26/2006, 1:46 AM
FAT32 remains as ever it did, no way it could change because the it'd be FAT64 I guess. However all is not lost. I believe the latest incarnations of OSX will mount a NTFS volume or for not many dollars one can buy MacDrive and format one of your own drive as HFS+ or mount one of her Mac drive.

Quicktime is only a wrapper, same as AVI. If here final edit is rendered out to DVCPro50 you can get a free DVCPro50 codec from Matrox I believe so you can owrk on this in Vegas. Failing that you could get her to render out to the BMD 2YUV codec with a QT wrapper and install the drivers from BMD and then work on that in Vegas. Bear ni mind that a DVCPro 50 file is twice the size of a DV25 file per minute and a BMD 2YUV QT file will be about 4 times the size. All of these are compressed video, an uncompressed file is HUGE!
Bob.
dhill wrote on 1/26/2006, 2:52 PM
Thanks again Bob! I'll try the NTFS first since that's much easier than the 2nd suggestion. I'll walk in the other room where my girlfriend has her Mac and see if it see's my drive. I just got another 1 TB G-Tech fw 800 drive, so, file size shouldn't be problem. DH