Is PAL a Cinderella for DVD Architect?

Unhurried wrote on 7/16/2003, 2:45 AM
I’m working with Vegas 3.0 – 4.0 for about a year. Now the time has come to transfer the results to DVD. Of course, my first choice was DVD Architect (hereafter DVDA). Not very good choice I guessed. I’m working with PAL everywhere (from camcorder to TV) and I immediately detected a DVDA’s (and Vegas's) perverted love of NTSC. One has to adjust respective parameter every time in more that one place, Vegas always try to force using NTSC. Well, no great loss without some small gain, so I accurately kill now all NTSC option whenever I meet it in every software. But DVDA annulled even this small gain! When I was preparing my first DVD I carefully examined the GUI and selected PAL. Unfortunately the produced DVD (say DVD+RW) was “crooked”, the picture jerked when the disk played in a DVD player. Examination of the disk with SmartRipper showed it is NTSC (!) disk coded as MPEG1 (!!). My colleagues using Scenarist software laughed at me…
Please, tell me what should I do to begin laughing at Scenarist users? It looks like DVDA incorrectly uses some flags. Maybe I can solve the problem via Windows Registry correction? Tell me where! But maybe DVDA is for NTSC users only? Well, I’ll find another DVD authoring program. But Sonic Foundry’s environment (Sound Forge – CD Architect - Vegas Video – DVD Architect) looks so comfortable! I like comfort!
P.S. DVDA version 1.0c, all the source materials were processed as PAL.
P.P.S. Special question to DVDA team: WHY DVDA accepts program streams only (NOT elementary streams)? And more, WHEN DVDA will accept elementary streams as well?

Comments

PeterWright wrote on 7/16/2003, 3:07 AM
Don't know what's going on with yours, but I've done several PAL DVDA projects without any problems.

My DVDA opens up with PAL defaults (check "Open all new projects with these settings" under File > Properties).

Sorry - no help for your situation - don't know what's causing it - except to say that what you're after is possible ...

peter
Unhurried wrote on 7/16/2003, 8:48 AM
Thank you for the quick response! I see the problem looks very strange. It was important for me to be sure somebody has made his own PAL DVD without problem. Otherwise I forget about DVDA until I see version 2.0 at least. Now I’m going to wait a bit for another advises (remember, there is P.P.S. in my posting). And I start looking for ReelDVD manual.
CrazyRussian wrote on 7/16/2003, 9:01 PM
Dont know what's up with your PAL settings, I'm in NTSC world but burned some PAL for Russia. Nobody complained.
I also would like why DVDA accept only program streams, and when it will accept elementary???

ReelDVD??? Well, I guess you can switch to it, you would need to STUDY the manual in order to be able to navigate and make menu for simple projects. What is done in DVDA in one day, takes a week in ReelDVD
Just MHO
Unhurried wrote on 7/17/2003, 12:32 AM
Hi, zemelya!
Cherkni paru strok na titova@rbcmail.ru, PLEASE!
vonhosen wrote on 7/17/2003, 5:51 PM
The only way you will be able to laugh at a Scenarist user is how much they pay for it.
seeker wrote on 7/17/2003, 9:10 PM
vonhosen,

" The only way you will be able to laugh at a Scenarist user is how much they pay for it. "

I was thinking the same thing. It would be overly optimistic to hope that DVD-A can compete with Scenarist any time soon. But hope springs eternal, and I am hoping.

-- Seeker --
Unhurried wrote on 7/18/2003, 9:21 AM
It's easy to solve the problem: I'm not a profi and I'll make a few DVDs a year. Well, I'll come to my friend using Scenarist and ask hem to work on his computer a few evenins. If I'll bring a bit beer, he's happy! ;-)