OT: Answering Machine Recommendation?

Coursedesign wrote on 11/2/2005, 10:47 AM
I have been through many answering machines for my home. Most of them had very poor clarity of messages due to way excessive compression to squeeze out the last cent of manufacturing cost.

Only one machine was good ever, and that was an AT&T (1740 I think) but it died and indications are that many others experienced the same problem.

Can anyone recommend an answering machine?

My requirements:

1. Clarity
2. Clarity
3. Clarity
4. Remote message pickup
5. One line is sufficient
6. Caller ID would be nice, but will sacrifice if I have to.

I have searched everywhere and looked in the usual bigbox stores. All junk, as far as I can see.

Phone company voice mail is not OK. You have to pick up the receiver to check if any voice mail has come in (I do have a phone that can receive a signal from the phone company VM, but this is indicated by a dim LED behind a dark plexiglas front...). That sucks. Also, who doesn't hate those VM menus?

I just replaced my 12 year old B&O super Hi-Fi phone with a new Enzer phone from Newegg. $50 and definitely high sound quality, although not in B&O league, looks decent though and has a good speaker phone feature.

Now I've got to up the hifi on the messages.

Last resort would be to use a PC program that records WAV....

Comments

jeremyk wrote on 11/2/2005, 11:52 AM
I have an AT&T 1719 bought a year ago at Best Buy for $20. It was the only model of plain answering machine they carried, and I bought it reluctantly, thinking it must be cheap junk.

Surprise -- it's the best answering machine I've ever owned. Clear audio, sensible user interface, plenty of features. It even announces caller IDs, if you want.

Of course, that was last year's model. Don't know if it's still around.
JJKizak wrote on 11/2/2005, 2:07 PM
Try to get one also with at least a 4 digit access code as one of the scams is to dial into your access code as a third party and you get charged for the call while your phone is still on hook. I haven't had a clear ATT one for a long time since the bean counters pulled the strings.

JJK
craftech wrote on 11/3/2005, 6:28 PM
Coursedesign,
Answering machines have gone the way of VCR's and camcorders in terms of quality - downhill. You cant even find a tape machine anymore.
I researched it thoroughly for you and the best I could find are a choice between the:

GE 29869 and the AT&T 1738.

Not glowing reviews, but decent for what is available today.

John
Coursedesign wrote on 11/3/2005, 6:32 PM
Many thanks for this!

I'll see what I can get my hands on.

Almost odd that no vendor cares.

craftech wrote on 11/3/2005, 6:47 PM
The Panasonic KX TM150 is also good but I don't think you will be able to find one anymore.

John
Bob Greaves wrote on 11/3/2005, 7:25 PM
It is possible to convert an old computer into an answering machine using answering machine software. The quality can be as good as you like. I used to create the outgoing messages in my recording studio - but the downside is you need a computer running 24/7.

I have not done it for a number of years but I still have an older program that runs under windows 3.11 and Win 95 that could handle up to 100 lines when connected to a complex modem. It allows voice mail, mail box if you want and it will even forward calls based on caller ID to a second phone line like a cell phone to transfer that important call. You can record all your own voice mail prompts or use the ones provided.

check out
http://www.internetsoftsolution.com/
http://www.nch.com.au/ivm/
http://www.pppindia.com/answer/
http://www.modemtools.com/answering-machine-software.htm
http://www.imptec.com/callstation.htm