Hi Guys,
I am definitely on the enthusiasts - side of things here and nowhere near pro or semi-pro - but I love videoing and editing and using Vegas and I enjoy this group even if I am a bit "junior" for a lot of the stuff in it.
Have been using miniDV for about 4 years and and pretty happy with it. I burn DVDs import to Vegas do whatever I want.
I am in the Market for a new camcorder - (family/fun sports - some paid stuff of peoples affairs - but nothing serious) and honestly my main reason is the cool factor and simple to carry and encorage me to use more. (capture to memory card or drive - quick copy to PC - new features etc.)
(I live in Israel and almost no one has HD TVs - almost no one has 16:9 etc.) The videos I make for people (usually either presentations for their family events -or of their family events) seem to be fine using miniDV raw from a consumer camera - input and regular DVDs/mpeg2 and even Youtube output. I don't yet have Blu-Ray and very few people have them here - nor do they have PS3s)
I know it is better today to capture things in a better format so that in the future when needed I have better source to work with.
WHAT SEEMS to blow me away from what I keep reading - is that to do the simple workflow that I do today .. Video it - import to Vegas - Edit - make a DVD of it - seems TO BE MUCH HARDER if I switch to a newer "better" format. HD or AVCHD.
I need to run conversion software to downgrade the quality of my video -so I can use it on my Dual core machine running vegas -etc. Must jump through hoops to make regular DVDs that are not Blu-Ray etc ..
Then I read other articles about getting worse quality from AVCHD than I am used to with mini DV because of compressions issues proprietary formats etc.
I am really impressed (from reading not seeing) with the Canon Vixia HF-100 and the Sony HDR-SR11(which may be too expensive) and just saw the JVC GZ-HD30 - but I am wondering if (given that this is not a need- but rather a "want") it is just not a completely baked technology and buying today will be frustrating?
So after the ramblings here are the questions /issues
1. Is there a simple well written Idiots guide to understand the various HD and Psuedo HD formats?
2. Is there a normal simple way to just as easily as I do today make and edit videos and DVDS that play on normal players - while still saving high quality footage that I can do better things with in the future.
3. Is AVCHD is real standard or is it a transitional technology that will not last long and is not so good to have now.
4. What is the best "fun" cool gadgety camcorder to get today - 6-700 max that will give me good quality video - in an easy NON-proprietary format ...
Thanks for listening to my ramblings - but I bet I may not be the only one ...
Allen
I am definitely on the enthusiasts - side of things here and nowhere near pro or semi-pro - but I love videoing and editing and using Vegas and I enjoy this group even if I am a bit "junior" for a lot of the stuff in it.
Have been using miniDV for about 4 years and and pretty happy with it. I burn DVDs import to Vegas do whatever I want.
I am in the Market for a new camcorder - (family/fun sports - some paid stuff of peoples affairs - but nothing serious) and honestly my main reason is the cool factor and simple to carry and encorage me to use more. (capture to memory card or drive - quick copy to PC - new features etc.)
(I live in Israel and almost no one has HD TVs - almost no one has 16:9 etc.) The videos I make for people (usually either presentations for their family events -or of their family events) seem to be fine using miniDV raw from a consumer camera - input and regular DVDs/mpeg2 and even Youtube output. I don't yet have Blu-Ray and very few people have them here - nor do they have PS3s)
I know it is better today to capture things in a better format so that in the future when needed I have better source to work with.
WHAT SEEMS to blow me away from what I keep reading - is that to do the simple workflow that I do today .. Video it - import to Vegas - Edit - make a DVD of it - seems TO BE MUCH HARDER if I switch to a newer "better" format. HD or AVCHD.
I need to run conversion software to downgrade the quality of my video -so I can use it on my Dual core machine running vegas -etc. Must jump through hoops to make regular DVDs that are not Blu-Ray etc ..
Then I read other articles about getting worse quality from AVCHD than I am used to with mini DV because of compressions issues proprietary formats etc.
I am really impressed (from reading not seeing) with the Canon Vixia HF-100 and the Sony HDR-SR11(which may be too expensive) and just saw the JVC GZ-HD30 - but I am wondering if (given that this is not a need- but rather a "want") it is just not a completely baked technology and buying today will be frustrating?
So after the ramblings here are the questions /issues
1. Is there a simple well written Idiots guide to understand the various HD and Psuedo HD formats?
2. Is there a normal simple way to just as easily as I do today make and edit videos and DVDS that play on normal players - while still saving high quality footage that I can do better things with in the future.
3. Is AVCHD is real standard or is it a transitional technology that will not last long and is not so good to have now.
4. What is the best "fun" cool gadgety camcorder to get today - 6-700 max that will give me good quality video - in an easy NON-proprietary format ...
Thanks for listening to my ramblings - but I bet I may not be the only one ...
Allen