I'm glad to see others discover this. I spent a fair bit of time researching the intracies of making text look right in video. Video places a lot of contrainst on how text can be presented and the software needs to understand that.
The thing is years ago well before the idea of the NLE came along dedicated racks of hardware were able to produce exceptionally good looking text in video. I suspect a lot of the knowledge that went into the design of those units got lost in the rush for fancier looking stuff.
Text crawl and credit rolls are quite difficult to get looking right, I know, I've spent more hours than I should have had to to nut out how to make it look right.
One question for Cayman, I hope at least one of the beta testers is testing it in PAL?
Peter,
from what I know it doesn't even need to plug in to Vegas, nice when it does but you can render out from it in a number of formats and bring that into Vegas.
Certainly placing text is easier when it's a plugin but hardly a show stopper.
One thing that concerns me though is with some text FXs (credit rolls for example) the text itself should specify the duration not the other way around which is where it's totally wrong in Vegas. I don't quite know how that'd be integrated within Vegas.
Yes Bob, but if it doesn't plug in smoothly, it becomes one of many progs that can produce impressive looking tgas or whatever that can be hoisted onto the Vegas timeline.
I'm hoping for the abilty to adjust any properties "live" whilst looping within Vegas as we now do with the Text Media Generator.
Peter,
that's exactly what I'm hoping you cannot do, if you can do that then it'll be just another graphics app shoehorned into video that produces lousy looking text. You simply cannot take a credit roll that takes 60 seconds and make it run in 58 seconds or 62 seconds. You could have it run in 30 seconds or 120 seconds though and those times also depend on whether the project is PAL or NTSC.
You can I believe overcome those limitations with sub pixel rendering but that could involve a high processor overhead.
Then there's the aliasing issues to consider. To get good small fonts in video you cannot just position any font anywhere in the frame.
Try both. Trial downloads of both are availble. Even though the Vegas plugin hasn't been released, you can still play with them and see which one you prefer or, at $149 vs. $395, can afford. :-)