Premiere audio better than Vegas?

PeterWright wrote on 11/23/2002, 3:28 AM
This week I bought an external F/W drive to use with my Vaio laptop, and experienced the dreaded "Unable to mix audio. Operation timed out" error when trying to play back from the timeline.

Since then I have searched various Vegas forums and read through many threads about this, going back several months. Although not all external F/W HD users have had the problem, many have.

It seems that various remedies or improvements have been tried, sometimes successfully, sometimes not. It seems to be worse when a single clip is split and crossfaded with itself - causing a high demand on the seek function.

It seems that SF are aware of the situation and there has been mention that the new audio engine used in Acid 4 does not seem to have the same problem, and this will probably be ported to the next version of Vegas.

Today I installed Premiere 6.02 on my laptop for the first time, purely to try it out with the firewire drive. To my astonishment there were no playback problems at all!
One of the many areas in which Vegas generally "kills" Premiere has been Audio, and yet AP doesn't stall like Vegas does, even with a single DV stereo track.

As I am very keen to start using my laptop with firewire drive - and Vegas, I would love to hear if there has been any progress towards solving this.

Comments

JonnyMac wrote on 11/23/2002, 12:55 PM
I really have to believe it's something in your setup. I'm running Vegas on a 600 MHz PIII laptop (2.5 years old -- new 2.2 gig machine is on order) with an external FW drive and I have had ZERO problems. In fact, I tossed Premiere 6.03 after just one day of working with Vegas.

Make sure you turn off any unnecessary background programs or processes that can intefere with Vegas's realtime operation.

-- Jon McPhalen
-- Dallas, TX
murk wrote on 11/23/2002, 1:38 PM
Vegas audio blows away premiere, not even close
PeterWright wrote on 11/23/2002, 6:25 PM
"Vegas audio blows away premiere, not even close"

Yes I know, that's why I used an ironic Subject heading!

And that's why it does seem very strange that the same files on the same hard drive on the same laptop play ok in Premiere but not in Vegas.

I'll try and see if there is anything unnecessary going on in the background - can anyone point me to any help in deciding which of the "Processes" in XP Pro can be dispensed with, and which are vital?

Thanks

BillyBoy wrote on 11/23/2002, 6:36 PM
I've seen the error message you got a few times. Always for me it seems somehow a track got corrupted. Simply adding a new audio track and moving all the events fixed it.