Support for HD Content on Red Laser DVD

john_dennis wrote on 5/29/2010, 6:24 PM
My daughter bought a 42 inch Samsung plasma panel and a Samsung BD-C5500 Blu-ray Player last night. Though I was not part of the product selection process as "Dad" I was part of the installation and setup process. Of course, she bought Avatar to try the system out. The player posted a message when the Avatar Blu-ray was inserted that a firmware update was required to play the disk.

While downloading the firmware update, I tried some of my personal video written as Blu-ray (BDMV format) on DVD-5 and DVD-9. They would not play. My BD-R disks would play, however. I didn't have much hope that the firmware update would fix the problem, but it did!

The informative thing about this experience is that trying the media in stores on display equipment may not be an accurate test of device capabilities with current firmware. Manufacturers tend not to stop the lines to cut in the latest firmware and devices sit in-transit and inventory before they are sold.

Comments

richard-amirault wrote on 5/29/2010, 7:29 PM
While downloading the firmware update, I tried some of my personal video written as Bluray (BDMV format) on DVD-5 and DVD-9. They would not play. My BD-R disks would play, however. I didn't have much hope that the firmware update would fix the problem, but it did!

I would not have tried to view anything *during* the download process ... just to be safe. But, glad that you can now play those disks.
A. Grandt wrote on 5/30/2010, 4:19 AM
I am paranoid when it comes to firmware updates. why it isn't mandatory for hardware vendors to have it be recoverable from a botched firmware is beyond me.
And it is very easy to do, have the basic boot sequence and flash writer in ROM. They save $2 (if that) and we risk bricking a fortune whenever we patch.

Sorry, I just needed to get that rant out of my system. I tend to see red whenever the talk comes to Firmwares and having to be overly cautious about updating them.
"Do not turn off the machine or power before the Firmware update is complete". I've tried that. I didn't turn off the power, the whole bloody city just went dark at an inopportune moment. Didn't change the outcome though, I was left with a bricked DVD burner.
gpsmikey wrote on 5/30/2010, 8:28 AM
"the whole bloody city just went dark at an inopportune moment." ????

Good grief !! some people just have to take Murphy's law to a whole new level. I too always get a bit nervous when updating things (especially things like my router or digital Camera). You're right about having a fallback "restore" mode. Lots of flash memory these days can be partitioned so that the bootloader code is in one segment of the chip and the actual operating code is in another partition of the chip. Gives the option of always being able to get to the boot loader since it is not overwritten.

mikey
craftech wrote on 5/31/2010, 5:30 AM
If you go over to the AVS Forum you can look up threads regarding your specific player. I can tell you this. There were similar complaints regarding Avatar and firmware updates for my Panasonic BR player and I imagine other players as well. Avatar played better on mine before the firmware update.

John