Survey: What's your favorite Transition(s) for a picture montage?

Comments

stepfour wrote on 12/18/2004, 9:23 AM
For me it depends on the project. Slideshows is almost always simple crossfades (Cuts on fast slideshows) and maybe an occasional page peel to dramatically seperate sections on slideshows that cover several eras or key events. For sports, dancing and video with a lot of motion and upbeat music, scmoores Cubes transition works great and looks very good. Chienworks also has a couple of beautiful wipes that I use sometimes. The transitions I never use are stuff like barndoors.
AlanC wrote on 12/20/2004, 9:07 AM
For stills with a punchy theme, I sometimes use a transition that isn't a transition, if you see what I mean.

Zoom in to somebody wearing shades, or a framed photograph or a mirror. Whatever the object, using chroma key set it up with your next image so that it appears to be a reflection in the first. Then zoom in to the shades (or whatever) until your second image over rides the first.

Did anybody understand that? :~)

Alan
TielBr wrote on 12/22/2004, 1:15 AM
Yes,... Very cool!
Grazie wrote on 12/22/2004, 2:02 AM
Yes . .ditto.
AlanC wrote on 12/22/2004, 3:00 AM
So did it take you 2 days to figure out what I was trying to say - or 2 days to try it out? :~)

Alan
c2323j wrote on 12/22/2004, 8:48 AM
I have a question...when I started using Vegas and did crossfades I would get a blue crossing line when intersecting to items, now it seems to look like a box (clear). how do I get the old look (blue crossing lines, etc.) without resetting the software.
FrigidNDEditing wrote on 12/22/2004, 10:23 AM
IMO (In My Opinion - for those that are new to forums) I say it's all about content. I don't like a bunch of fancy stuff unless it's a high tempo song, etc... I have done more than my fair share of photo montage's to Narations and music (as I'm sure many of us have) and have found that I am always going to have a better slide show if I take the time to do timed cuts to the music/naration than if I just do every x number of seconds or something. (as long as they pay me enough) :)

When I watch a photo montage, I find that it's going to be better if you simply let the song/Narration dictate the montage. Your entire show is in there somewhere, the only thing you have to do is find it, and then display it for everyone to see. [This "show" is often times different for different people, but the same for everyone (if that makes sense)] meaning that if you've done it "right", even though someone else may have made it differently, they see yours and it feels right to them.

Well, there's my 2 cents. well, maybe it's only worth 1 1/2 but I don't have a hay penny here. so I'll round it up :)

Dave
TomE wrote on 12/22/2004, 11:22 AM
Using the photomontage how do you choose the simple crossfade in the transition preset? I did not see it listed in the transisitons when I clicked on the edit. So if I want to use the soft flash and a crossfade how do I set that in Ultimate S photomontage?

I am in the middle of scanning over 1000 slides from the 1940s to 2003 for a family. I have only gotten through the 40's and 50's and was trying to figure out how to give this to the family. Just burn a DVD and use the Roxio slideshow with music and put the slides on for them to print out later. Or Bring it into Vegas. Wow then I tried the Ulitmate S photomontage and in under a second it put the pan and zooms in and I was half way there.

I agree with a lot of the people here that too many transitions can look amatuerish. I try to stick with the crossfades and the soft flash for a slower piece and straignt cuts or pushes left or right with a faster piece. Page peels and such are not my style.

Anyway Vegas again is the answer for me.

-Tom
beatnik wrote on 12/22/2004, 11:23 AM
KEEP IT SIMPLE.

I use crossfades ONLY. I will also use the pan and crop feature
to zoom around on perhaps 10% of the GOOD slides that are worthy of
such an effect.

At the beginning of the slide show..just after the intro I will use the "FLASH"
transition along with a sound effect "CAMERA SHUTTER"

The reason I do this is because I create VideoTours of homes for sale
for the real estate industry. At the end of each VideoTour I will include
a slideshow as a recap of the tour. Just when the video has ended
I fade to black and a flash and camera shuter starts the slideshow.

check out http://www.videolistings.ca and view one of the VideoTours
and wait for the slide show.
Dezine wrote on 12/22/2004, 11:50 AM
I am a fan of Keep it simple as well.
I generally use crossfades with straight cuts, depending on teh pace and feel of the music that I'm working with.
However I do employ the use of some special trasititions like using layering like "The Kid Stays in the Picture". But I also like to occasionaly use object wipes. I use an Alpha mask on a particular picture, place on a new track above my current track, and using track motion or Pan Crop move the picture across the screen while increasing size, then fade out quickly. That creates a wipe effect that reveals the picture below.
An example:
1. Track A (my main video track) has a picture of a man getting on a train.
2. I make track B, put it above track A and place a picture of a Train (alpha masked out).
3. Employ the method described above and now teh train will be used a a trasition to reveal hte piture of the man getting on the train.

I hope this helps a bit with some additional creative inspiration.

MLiebergot
LVProductions
FrankLP wrote on 12/22/2004, 11:59 AM
Depends on the "feeling" I'm trying to create and if I am syncing transitions to a soundtrack. Usually simple crossfades are best for tranquil/no-nonsense imagery. But the sky's the limit if it's a high energy piece...everything from Spice stuff to masking (the old Tool Time-type transition).