.mov deforemes video

Former user wrote on 11/28/2023, 9:14 AM

@Led00 Hi, there might be another reason but often aliasing occurs when an image is increased in size, What render aspect size are you rendering at compared to your project size?

PS, that video you shared, how was it made? Some players don't play my .mov very well.

For instance this is how MPC player shows this

but it should look more like this

----------------

😂🤦‍♂️ That png shows on this forum with transparency, I've added a black background

Former user wrote on 11/28/2023, 9:47 AM

This rendered with this option plays fine,

& looks fine when dragged back into Vegas

john_dennis wrote on 11/28/2023, 10:32 AM

@Led00

Place the two files on a cloud share and post the link here.

mark-y wrote on 11/28/2023, 11:12 AM

Try different Alpha settings in your Media Properties --

Led00 wrote on 11/29/2023, 8:14 AM

First of all, thank you for trying to help me, it is nice to see helpful community.

@Former user I dont know how it was made, I got it like this to use it in my project.

@mark-y thanks, something happened, I am attaching a sample (first part is how it should look like, second is mov with different alpha settings).

I am sending both files via WeTransfer, and my question would be how to get the mp4 version like, but with transparency. I just realised that, before, .mov version was not deformed when i would play it on my old PC, but now, every player I have shows it deformed. Is it how it is packed?

https://we.tl/t-zGjpqdTpRm

Former user wrote on 11/29/2023, 8:58 AM

First of all, thank you for trying to help me, it is nice to see helpful community.

@Former user I dont know how it was made, I got it like this to use it in my project.

@Led00 Hi, I downloaded your vids.

The orig is MP4 so there's no alpha, when I added it to the track with chromakey there's a lot of 'noise' around the lines, you seem to have removed the black quite well in the ,mov, so I ignored the orig.

Can you explain how you removed the black from the orig MP4?

Adding your .mov & i changed the alpha to Straight, then rendered with this setting (wrong frame rate but I changed it later to 30p which didn't adversely affect the render)

Yours dragged back in with nothing altered

Mine dragged in with nothing altered

This is how it went

mark-y wrote on 11/29/2023, 10:33 AM

@Led00 Here is how the Media Alpha options look in VP18. To find the Alpha options, right-click on the media or media event and select Properties.

That said, there are better .mov choices with Alpha that have cleaner edges than RLE encoding. Explanation: RLE encoding contains rounding errors, most likely visible as chroma jitter. Let me know what's available in your graphic generator and we can try some suggestions.

john_dennis wrote on 11/29/2023, 10:45 AM

I don't have Quicktime loaded on this machine so I couldn't open your .MOV file. I converted your .MOV file to ProRes 4444XQ using Shutter Encoder.

Here is a rendered result.

mark-y wrote on 11/29/2023, 12:13 PM

Just playing with track compositing.

Led00 wrote on 12/1/2023, 5:42 AM

Once again, thank you all for your effort. I have menaged to recreate your solutions and got to pretty much same results, but the result itself is the problem. If you look at my previous post with video sample once again, you will notice that the behavior of the lines is different in the two samples. The first one (mp4) has lines mostly parallel and their movement is somewhat smooth. Mov version has the same lines, but they look kind of a loose, animation is different. Not sure how is that even possible, but that is my problem. I need it to look and behave the same as mp4, but with transperency.

Thank you all.

Dexcon wrote on 12/1/2023, 5:59 AM

If you want blacks in a video to become transparent, one long existing way to do that in Vegas Pro is to render the intended transparent video to .AVI by the Video for Windows template. Customise the chosen template by changing the 'Video format' field to Uncompressed and checking the 'Render alpha channel ..." (assuming that .mov is a supported codec - that I don't know) and then render. The downside to this is that the resultant uncompressed .avi file is huge - but it does work (caveat - I don't know if it works with .mov media).

set wrote on 12/1/2023, 7:09 AM

ProRes HQ can work:

for transparency

Former user wrote on 12/1/2023, 7:58 AM

Once again, thank you all for your effort. I have menaged to recreate your solutions and got to pretty much same results, but the result itself is the problem. If you look at my previous post with video sample once again, you will notice that the behavior of the lines is different in the two samples. The first one (mp4) has lines mostly parallel and their movement is somewhat smooth. Mov version has the same lines, but they look kind of a loose, animation is different. Not sure how is that even possible, but that is my problem. I need it to look and behave the same as mp4, but with transperency.

@Led00 I see the difference 👍

How did you remove the black from the orig mp4? when I add Chromakey or any other keying fx I get a lot of noise that's hard to remove.

------------

This is that mp4 with ChromaKey - Black, no adjustments to remove the noise..

Exported as ProRes XQ as I did earlier

Led00 wrote on 12/3/2023, 6:51 AM

So, I went a step back to check something, and found that they sent me two different work versions, that is why the animation is different. Anyway, with that fixed and all your advices, I was able to achieve what I needed. Thank you all and see you next time! :)