Just to be fair, this was a post about humor....... Bud just ............ Bud! ;-) When I read Bud's posts I have images of him running around in a hotel with an axe, with cameras taped to his head and the axe, re-interacting "the shinning" ! ;-)
With Course posts, I see him in a converted temple into an Apple store, wearing long *&^%^&, pasting out incenses and free passes for intestinal cleaning at the GENIUS BAR. ;-)
..."You know you're an amateur when you throw a lot of technical jargon around to make people think your comment is above reproach.
OR
You answer a post, without fully reading or understanding it, based on a few buzz words you saw, and your answer is just a giant bloviation*..........""
I just want a straight answer. Was this post directly referring to me?
I think this thread is hilarious. I feel that everyone is talking directly about me, but I think I am exempt because I don't even qualify as an amateur. What is below amateur? Idiot?
But I will add this: You know your an amateur when you think owning the Pro Version directly means you are a pro.
OR
You guess your way around the program without a clue what you are doing, then when it all goes to heck, you email Sony and tell them they have serious problems with the software (funny thing is when your right).
Since I am officially unable to call another forum member an "idiot" perhaps you all can tell me which other term might be acceptable. Here is the list of candidates:
"But I will add this: You know your an amateur when you think owning the Pro Version directly means you are a pro. "
I've had a client, nice guy actually, salt of the earth kind of yokel that you'd trust your life with without even thinking, tell me he had a "professional" tripod. He bought it with him one day, just to prove it. Sure enough, engraved very nicely on one of the silver diecast legs was the word "Professional" in English and Chinese.
I suppose you may as long as you can prove that you actually know the definition of those terms or can at least prove that you know how to find them in a dictionary. Oh, right, you already failed that test earlier today. Then I guess you may not add to the list. :)
'professional' is one of those much abused words nowadays that can be applied to literally ANYTHING; professional knives, professional tyres, (are there professional condoms?).
'amateur' is, in my case, usually applied to anyone coming to me with a problem - if they were professional they wouldn't have a problem. (exceptions are obvious - technical failures, senior moments, etc.,)
what makes an amateur a professional (even unpaid), is the willingness to listen to GOOD advice, and be just as willing to pass GOOD advice along....
For a thread that started as 'humour' it sure got heavy! Going with that, in the film/video business maybe we get too 'precious' about the term "professional", as indeed has been said above. The serious amateur is quite professional in pursuing their activity. Confusing? Generally by professional we mean "earns significant proportion of overall income", while hoping others perceive it as meaning "expert in the field". Looking up some references http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professionaldiscussion of the term[/link] and the Oxford we would be safer calling it a "trade", although of course these days people get college qualifications and so fit the academic aspirations of the definition (rather than learning the trade on the job). As in any trade, there are good and bad practitioners and in the end the market sorts us out. Some might claim "professional" is limited to those who are members of craft organisations (such as The American Society of Cinematographers -- and equivalent national bodies) and that would apply a severe filter. Also technical expertise is not the defining hallmark of those trying to earn a crust in this business, as we see skimming professional sites such as CML. Economic pain? We could go with that!
I'm going to check my Ginsu knives, they're supposed to be commercial grade.
==============================================
Sure enough, engraved very nicely on one of the silver diecast legs was the word "Professional" in English and Chinese.